Removing his fingers, Jude picked up the plug and coated it generously with the lube. When he parted Liam’s ass again and nudged the entrance with the tip of the plug, the younger man almost blew right then.

“Oh! Shit! I can’t-”

“Sure, you can. The plug isn’t any bigger than the one I used before, and it’s not nearly as big as me. But you’ll be filled and it will drive you crazy.”

“B-but I want you.”

What an adorable pout, which was clear in his voice. But Jude wasn’t diverted from his mission, and began to push the device slowly into his channel.

Lily stared, fascinated, as the small phallus split their lover’s flesh. As he writhed, completely giving himself over to what was done to him.

“That’s it,” Jude said, soothing him. “All the way, take it for me.”

“So full.”

“I know. There you go; it’s in.”

It was in, to the base. Liam continued to make helpless noises in his throat while Jude picked up the thin leather strap.

“Now turn around and face me for a second,” he said.

Liam did as he was told, careful not to slip. When Jude reached for his cock holding the leather, he blinked. “What are you doing?”

“Putting this cock ring on you. Hold still.”

“Damn, you’re a sadist.”

“Exactly.” Jude looked pleased with himself. “It’ll display your package and keep you nice and hard while I paddle your pretty ass.”

“Wh-what?” His eyes rounded. “Oh, no. Uh-uh. You’re not-”

“Turn around and grab the rim again,” Jude ordered sternly. “You wanted this attention-this punishment-and now you’re going to get it.”

Swallowing hard, the younger man did as he was told, presenting his bottom. Angling her head to see him from the side, Lily noted his erection was harder than ever. He did want this, even though he was nervous.

“Lily, hand me the paddle.” She complied, and he gave his palm a few experimental whacks as Liam flinched. “Lily, I’ll need you to let me know if I’m marking his skin too deeply.”

“All right.”

“Liam, you’ll need to tell me when you’ve reached your limit,” he said, smoothing the other man’s buttocks with his palm. “But you’ll need a safe word.”

“Why? I trust you.”

“That’s good, but when sexual pain is involved, sometimes a person can get caught up saying no when they mean yes. Or they forget their own limits and can’t verbalize that they really are ready to stop. Does that make sense?”

“Yes,” he said.

“Good. Pick a safe word, one you wouldn’t normally say. If you say that word, I’ll stop, but otherwise not before I’m ready.”

“Okay, um… sailboat.”

“Fine. I’m going to start lightly. Ready?”

“I guess so.”

Lily couldn’t tear her gaze away as Jude swung. The paddle slapped Liam’s bare ass and he yelped, more in surprise than pain, she figured. Jude delivered another swat, then another, each increasing in force.

“Oh! God…” Liam pushed his rear toward the blows, cock bobbing on the water, high and hard.

As she watched, fascinated, he seemed to settle into a zoned-out head space. His cries increased in volume, but they were cries of pain mingled with ecstasy. His ass had turned a bright red and Lily wondered if she should intervene.

“Jude! Fuck! I-I… stop, please!”

“Do you really want me to stop?”

More blows, Liam yelling hoarsely.

“No. Yes! Stop!”

“Use your safe word.”

Another blow. One more.

“Sailboat! Ah, God.” Liam slumped forward, hanging on to the side, head on his arms.

Jude stopped and laid aside the paddle. “You did well, my friend. Are you still hard?”

“Jesus, yes,” he croaked. “I’m going to die.”

“Sit on the rim on the tub.”

“Why on the rim?” he asked, squirming.

“One, so you don’t get too hot in the water while you wait. Two, sitting on the lip will keep the plug shoved up inside you, keep you nice and open for me.”

“While I wait? What will you be doing?”

Jude smiled. “You’re going to sit there and be tortured more while I make sure Lily gets some attention of her own.”

Lily blinked. Oh, boy.

It was her turn to squirm. Because she knew what was left in the bag.

Fourteen

“Hand me the bag and assume the same position Liam did, sweetheart.”

“Yeah, it’s only fair,” Liam grouched, cock and balls thrust forward in their confines.

“What are you going to do?” she asked, pulse fluttering as she handed it over.

“If I told you, it wouldn’t be a surprise.” Fishing inside, he removed the dildo. Thick, long, and veined, the thing was unbelievably realistic.

Well, except for being black as ebony.

Turning around, she spread herself as Liam had done, excited but not terribly concerned. She’d used her own dildo before, so this would be pleasurable. No big deal, but very nice.

What she did not expect was for Jude’s fingers to part her ass cheeks. To begin the same preparation on her hole.

“Oh, wait a minute-”

“Shh, just relax. Trust me,” he said. “I won’t hurt you.”

“But that thing is huge! Bigger than you, and that’s saying a lot.”

“Not to worry, I’ll make sure you’re ready. You’re going to look so pretty with me working this big, black cock in and out of your ass. Won’t she, Liam?”

“Fuck, yes. What are you waiting for?”

Her entrance was massaged, slowly and gently. Stretched bit by bit, his slippery fingers becoming two, three, then four wide. She felt a pinch at first, an uncomfortable burn, but afterward, the burn became heat that filtered to her pussy. Made her clit throb and her knees weak.

“Okay, you’re ready. Easy, baby. I’ll take this nice and slow.”

His fingers slid out and a blunt tip pressed against her hole. She gasped when it pushed inside, feeling like the head of a baseball bat. Enormous. So wicked.

By inches, he pushed it deep, all the way to her womb. So big she felt it there, brushing inside her. God, she might explode just from this, even if he never moved it again.

But she held back her orgasm, gripping the edge of the tub as he began to fuck her ass with the toy.

“Good girl. Is she beautiful, Liam?”

“Gorgeous,” he breathed. “A goddess. All that black hair falling down her back to tickle her ass, while you split it with a black cock. That’s why you bought it, didn’t you? To match her?”

“I did. Damn, I wish I could see.”

“Me, too. But take my word, she’s smokin’. You don’t have to see to know that.”

Jude increased the strength of the strokes, plunging the cock into her hard and fast. She was teetering on the brink, just barely.

And then he rubbed his lube- slicked fingers against her clit, kneading it furiously. “Ah! Yes!”

She shattered, bucking, as he wrung every last drop from her. Bracing her forearms on the side of the tub, she panted, coming down. She winced as he slid the toy out, leaving her feeling quite empty.

Boneless, she slid into the water again and flopped against the side, anxious to see what Jude would do next.

“Remember when you said you wanted to see me fuck Liam?” he asked.

“Yes.” She swallowed. “I never got to.”

“Now you will.”

“I’m in pain here,” Liam whined, stroking his poor bound cock. “Put me out of my misery.”

Wading over to him, Jude groped for his arm and pulled him up. “Turn around and spread for me, but this time bend all the way over and rest your arms on the side of the tub. I want you completely open to me.”

“Jesus, yes.”

Liam assumed the position and Jude got behind him, smacking one sore ass check with his open palm. Liam yelped in surprise.

“Do you let anyone else bury their cock in your ass, besides me and Dev?” Jude demanded playfully. “Do you let any of the other men have this?”

“Sometimes,” he said, voice shaking. “But it’s just not as satisfying with anyone else, you know? Same with Lily and Geneva. I play, sure, but no other women can compare to them.”