“You’re right,” I said, in firm agreement. “I need to concentrate my full attention on our prime suspects-the three clients on your list. Which brings me to my next question: Have any of them called you since we last spoke?”
“Yes!” she said, perking up and leaning forward in her chair. “I meant to tell you before, but I got lost in the past and forgot. Sam Hogarth called me last night! He wanted to schedule an appointment with Melody.”
“Oh, my gosh!” I said, pulse pounding. “What did you tell him?”
“I said she had gone out of town for a couple of weeks.”
“How did he react?”
“Calmly. He just asked when she was expected to return.”
“That’s it? You didn’t discuss anything else?”
“I asked him if he wanted me to set him up with another girl, but he said no, he’d wait for Melody to come back.”
“Did he sound sincere? I mean, do you think he really doesn’t know that Melody is dead?”
Sabrina shrugged and shook her head. “I couldn’t tell, Paige. I listened to his voice very carefully, trying to determine his mood and motives, but I couldn’t make out a thing. He sounded the way he always does-cordial but businesslike.”
“Like a politician,” I said, remembering the way Hogarth had shuffled me out of his office, smiling all the while.
“Exactly,” Sabrina agreed. “Hard to read. He did make the phone call, though. Do you think that means anything?”
“It means something, all right, but the question is what? If he was actually calling to make a date with Melody, it means he doesn’t know she’s dead, which means he’s definitely not the murderer. But if he was calling just to make it look like he doesn’t know she’s dead, it means he probably is the murderer. So there’s your answer in a nutshell: District Attorney Sam Hogarth is either the murderer, or he’s not. Any more questions?”
Sabrina groaned. She looked like I felt-confused and overwhelmed. “What a mess,” she said, rubbing her swollen eyes with her fingertips. “Will you ever be able to sort it all out?”
“God willing,” I said, though I had serious doubts He’d want to get involved.
“I know you went to see Candy at Saks yesterday,” Sabrina continued. “Was she able to help you at all?”
“Not really. They gave her such a short break we didn’t have much time to talk. I’ll try to see her again tonight or tomorrow. Meanwhile, you had dinner with her last night, right?”
“Yes, she came here for her monthly review. Charlotte made beef Wellington.”
“Monthly review?”
“I have each of my girls come to dinner once a month. It gives me the opportunity to study their appearance and inquire about their health, and it gives them a chance to talk about their personal lives and voice any grievances they might have with their clients.”
“Did you discuss the murder with Jocelyn… er, Candy? (I still hadn’t gotten used to the two-name game.)
“At length,” she said. “We shared our pain and relived our fondest memories of Melody. It was very therapeutic.”
“Did she say who she thought the murderer was?”
“She wouldn’t speculate.” Sabrina gave me a tired, burned-out look and said, “Like the rest of my girls, she’s in shock and can’t imagine who could have done such a horrible thing.”
A siren went off in my head, then shrieked its way to my tongue. “That’s not what she told me! She said she was convinced the killer was either Hogarth or Corona. She even used their first names. ‘It was either Sam or Tony,’ she said. ‘I’d stake my life on it.’ Then she claimed they were both ‘devils in disguise. ’ Why would she say this to me and not to you?”
Sabrina was visibly stunned and upset. “I haven’t the slightest idea,” she said. “I’ve always insisted that my girls give me an immediate report if they have any problems with their clients. It’s one of my strictest rules. It’s the only way I can monitor the customers and keep the girls safe. I set Candy up with both Hogarth and Corona a few times in the past-before Melody joined the agency-but she never had a bad word to say about either of them. On the contrary, she said she liked them both a lot. Believe me, if Candy had ever complained about their behavior or given me any reason to believe that they were ‘devils in disguise,’ I would never have introduced them to Melody. In fact, I would have dropped them from my client list altogether!”
My pulse was pounding again. Had I finally dug up a meaningful clue? “What about the present?” I asked. “Have you fixed Candy up with Hogarth or Corona recently?”
“No. After they met Melody, they always asked for her.”
“Was Candy bothered by this? Do you think she was jealous of Melody?”
“If she was, she never gave any indication. I was under the impression that they were good friends. Candy confided in me more than once that she liked Melody better than any of the other girls. She said it again just last night.”
“Does Candy always tell you the truth?”
“I trusted her completely-until now. She told you one thing and me another, so she’s obviously lying to somebody. But why? What could she possibly have to gain? She knew that you and I would talk about this, so she also knew her lie would be exposed.”
“That’s a reasonable assumption,” I said, “assuming that Candy was in a reasonable state of mind. But maybe she wasn’t. She could have been freaked out about something and not thinking logically. Or maybe something happened between my talk with her at Saks and your talk with her at dinner to change her mind about the two suspects’ guilt and discourage her from mentioning them to you.”
Maybe she was threatened in some way, I said to myself. (I didn’t want to frighten Sabrina.) “The point is,” I continued, “we can’t leap to any conclusions about Candy. This matter requires a thorough examination. So, I’m going to do my best to see and question her again tonight. What’s her schedule like? Have you set up any dates for her?”
“Just one-dinner and dancing with her regular Friday night client. They meet every week like clockwork.”
“What time does she usually get home?”
“Pretty late. Around two, two thirty in the morning. And she takes a swim after that, so-”
“Swim?”
“The Barbizon has a pool,” Sabrina said, “and Candy swims a few laps every night when she gets home. She says it washes away her sins.”
“That’s good to know,” I said. “I’ll take my bathing suit.”
ABOUT HALF AN HOUR LATER-AFTER ADVISING Sabrina of my investigative plans for the rest of the day and night-I left her luxurious lavender bedroom and made my way back to the entrance hall. Not surprisingly, Charlotte was waiting for me at the door. She had my jacket, beret, and purse in her hands. I thanked her for the delicious breakfast and edifying conversation, then slipped out of the apartment and down the hall to the elevator.
When I landed in the lobby, I checked my watch. It was eleven fifteen. I had just enough time to get uptown to my bank, which was near my office (or what used to be my office), before lunchtime, when all the local employees would rush in to cash their paychecks. With any luck, I could withdraw a few bucks from my savings account before Mike and Mario-or, worse, Pomeroy!-pranced in. I owed Abby eight dollars, counting the four I still had in my purse, and I figured I’d need about fifteen more to get through the night and the rest of the weekend. Drinks at the Copa were expensive.
I had all the time and luck a down-on-her-luck, out-of-work crime writer could reasonably ask for. I caught an uptown train immediately and arrived at the Lexington and 42nd Street station at eleven thirty-five. My bank was just around the corner, and not yet crowded, so I was able to walk right up to a teller’s window without waiting in line. I made out my check, collected ten singles and a fiver, and-footsteps echoing against the green marble walls and ultrahigh ceiling-fled the stately financial establishment before the noontime stampede began.