“Two birds with one stone?”

“Perhaps.”

“And the certain family member. That would be your brother?”

“It would be possible.”

“Possible,” Grace said. “But that wasn’t what happened here. You weren’t out to protect your brother.”

Their eyes met.

“I know,” Grace said.

“Oh?” Sandra took a sip. “Then why don’t you clue me in.”

“You were, what, twenty-seven years old? Fresh out of law school and working as a criminal lawyer?”

“Yes.”

“You were married. Your daughter was two years old. You were on your way to a promising career. And then your brother messed it all up for you. You were there that night, Sandra. At the Boston Garden. You were the other woman backstage, not Geri Duncan.”

“I see,” she said without a trace of worry. “And you know this how?”

“Jimmy X said one woman was a redhead – that’s Sheila Lambert – and the other, the one who was egging him on, had dark hair. Geri Duncan was a blonde. You, Sandra, had dark hair.”

She laughed. “And that’s supposed to be proof of something?”

“No, not in and of itself. I’m not even sure it’s relevant. Geri Duncan was probably there too. She might have been the one who distracted Gordon MacKenzie so you three could sneak backstage.”

Sandra Koval gave her a vague wave of the hand. “Go on, this is interesting.”

“Shall I just get to the heart of the matter?”

“Please do.”

“According to both Jimmy X and Gordon MacKenzie, your brother was shot that night.”

“He was,” Sandra said. “He was in the hospital for three weeks.”

“Which hospital?”

There was no hesitation, no eye twitch, no give at all. “Mass General.”

Grace shook her head.

Sandra made a face. “Are you telling me you checked every hospital in the Boston area?”

“No need,” Grace said. “There was no scar.”

Silence.

“You see, the bullet wound would have left a scar, Sandra. It’s simple logic. Your brother was shot. My husband had no scar. There’s only one way that can be so.” Grace put her hands on the table. They were quaking.

“I was never married to your brother.”

Sandra Koval said nothing.

“Your brother, John Lawson, was shot that day. You and Sheila Lambert helped drag him out during the melee. But his wounds were lethal. At least I hope they were, because the alternative is that you killed him.”

“And why would I do that?”

“Because if you took him to a hospital, they would have to report the shooting. If you showed up with a dead body – or even if you just dumped him on the street – someone would investigate and realize where and how he was shot. You, the promising lawyer, were terrified. I bet Sheila Lambert was too. The world went crazy when this happened. The Boston DA – hell, Carl Vespa – was on television demanding blood. So were all the families. If you got caught up in that, you’d be arrested or worse.”

Sandra Koval stayed quiet.

“Did you call your father? Did you ask him what to do? Did you contact one of your old criminal clients to help you? Or did you just get rid of the body on your own?”

She chuckled. “You have some imagination, Grace. Can I ask you something now?”

“Sure.”

“If John Lawson died fifteen years ago, who did you marry?”

“I married Jack Lawson,” Grace said. “Who used to be known as Shane Alworth.”

Eric Wu hadn’t held two men in the basement, Grace now realized. Just one. One who had sacrificed himself to save her. One who probably knew that he was going to die and wanted to scratch out some last truth in the only way left to him.

Sandra Koval almost smiled. “That’s a hell of a theory.”

“One that will be easy to prove.”

She leaned back and folded her arms. “I don’t understand something about your scenario. Why didn’t I just hide my brother’s body and pretend he ran away?”

“Too many people would ask questions,” Grace said.

“But that’s what happened to Shane Alworth and Sheila Lambert. They just disappeared.”

“True enough,” Grace admitted. “And maybe the answer has to do with your family trust.”

That made Sandra’s face freeze. “The trust?”

“I found the papers on the trust in Jack’s desk. I took them to a friend who’s a lawyer. It seems your grandfather set up six trusts. He had two children and four grandchildren. Forget the money for a second. Let’s talk about voting power. All of you got equal voting shares, divided six ways, with your father getting the extra four percent. That way your side of the family kept control of the business, fifty-two percent to forty-eight. But-and I’m not good with this stuff so bear with me-Grandpa wanted to keep it all in the family. If any of you died before the age of twenty-five, the voting power would be divided equally among the five survivors. If your brother died the night of the concert, for example, that would mean that your side of the family, you and your father, would no longer hold a majority position.”

“You’re out of your mind.”

“Could be,” Grace said. “But tell me, Sandra. What drove you? Was it fear of being caught-or were you worried about losing control of the family business? Probably a combination of both. Either way, I know you got Shane Alworth to take your brother’s place. It’ll be easy to prove. We’ll dig up old pictures. We can run a DNA test. I mean, it’s over.”

Sandra started drumming the table with her fingertips. “If that’s true,” she said, “the man you loved lied to you all these years.”

“That’s true no matter what,” Grace said. “How did you get him to cooperate anyway?”

“That question is supposed to be rhetorical, right?”

Grace shrugged. “Mrs. Alworth tells me that they were dirt poor. His brother Paul couldn’t afford college. She was living in a dump. But my guess is, you made a threat. If one member of Allaw went down for this, they all would. He probably thought he had no choice.”

“Come on, Grace. Do you really think a poor kid like Shane Alworth could pull off being my brother?”

“How hard would it be? You and your father helped, I’m sure. Getting an ID would be no problem. You had your brother’s birth certificate and the pertinent paperwork. You just say he had his wallet stolen. Screening was easier back then. He’d have gotten a new driver’s license, new passport, whatever. You found a new trust lawyer in Boston -my friend noticed the change from the one in Los Angeles – someone who wouldn’t know what John Lawson looked like. You, your dad, and Shane go in to his office together, all with proper ID – who would question that? Your brother had already graduated from Vermont University, so it wasn’t like he’d have to show up there with a new face. Shane could go overseas now. If someone bumped into him, well, he’d go by Jack and just say he was another John Lawson. It’s not an uncommon name.”

Grace waited.

Sandra folded her arms. “Is this the part where I’m supposed to crack and confess everything?”

“You? No, I don’t think so. But come on, you know it’s over. It won’t be any problem to prove that my husband wasn’t your brother.”

Sandra Koval took her time. “That may well be,” she said, her words coming out more measured now. “But I’m not sure I see any crime here.”

“How’s that?”

“Let’s say-again hypothetically-that you’re right. Let’s say I did get your husband to pretend to be my brother. That was fifteen years ago. There’s a statute of limitations. My cousins might try to fight me on the trust issue, but they wouldn’t want the scandal. We’d work it out. And even if what you said is true, my crime was hardly a big one. If I was at the concert that night, well, in the early days of that rabid frenzy, who could blame me for being scared?”

Grace’s voice was soft. “I wouldn’t blame you for that.”

“Right, so there you go.”

“And at first you didn’t really do anything that terrible. You went to that concert seeking justice for your brother. You confronted a man who stole a song your brother and his friend wrote. That’s not a crime. Things went wrong. Your brother died. There was nothing you could do to bring him back. So you did what you thought best. You played the terrible hand you were dealt.”