Letting his eyes take in the scene again, he moved up to the body. A few inches above Samuel’s hand was a sharp tear in the wool of his coat.
Touching it lightly, Baldwin could feel the stickiness, and his lip curled in distaste. “Yes, he was stabbed too. In the back.”
“What can have happened?”
“I’m not sure.” Baldwin’s eyes went to the other body on the bed. Taking the light from Edgar, he strode to the palliasse. “Ah!”
“What?” Simon followed him. “What have you found?”
“Look.” Baldwin turned, and in his hand was a short-bladed knife, its steel dulled with dried blood.
“This must be what killed them.”
Sir William’s voice came from the storeroom. “Sir Baldwin, there’s a knife out here too.”
“What?” The knight’s face registered astonishment for a moment, then he darted through to where the old knight stood frowning at a thin-bladed knife, turning it over and over in his hand.
Baldwin took it from him and studied it. “So what has happened here, then?” he muttered.
“I can guess,” said Sir Robert. “There were regular gambling games down here. The guards get bored too often, and then they resort to playing at dice. These two were obviously playing at some game, began arguing and soon came to blows. They stabbed each other.”
“That is a truly magnificent hypothesis,” murmured Baldwin, and the young knight gave a slight smile, pleased with the older man’s approbation. Simon could hear the dry sarcasm in his friend’s tone and for a moment his mood lightened.
“It would explain it, wouldn’t it?” the young knight said, glancing smugly at Simon.
“Oh, yes!” Baldwin’s voice registered emphatic agreement.
Smiling, Robert walked from the storeroom, stared briefly at the body on the bed, then went out. Hugh closed the door after him. Sir William had watched his son depart, but now his gaze returned to Baldwin, who was again studying Samuel’s figure. “So you aren’t convinced, Sir Baldwin?” he asked, his voice calm and steady.
“No. Not at all.”
“Why?”
“It is too simple on the one hand, and too difficult on the other. Oh, I am sure that the poor lad in there on his mattress died almost instantly from his wound. There was no blood, and I think that means he was dead in an instant. No blood always does seem to indicate a quick death. But this one, Samuel – he managed to stagger all the way out here, over from the bed, before dying.”
“So?”
“Sir William, this man bled a lot. Feel the back of his coat if you don’t believe me. There’s a good pool of blood here where he lies. Yet there’s no blood on the floor by Ronald’s palliasse, or from the bed to here. He was not stabbed there, he died here, where he fell.”
“But… but surely he could still have been killed by the other. Ronald must have stabbed him here, and then made his way back to his bed where he himself died.”
“I fear not. As I said, Ronald died almost instantaneously. What is stored in these boxes and things?”
The question caught Sir William unawares. “Out here? Food and some drink, I think. And spare cloth. Nothing much. Why?”
“I just wondered why this man would have wanted to come out here.” Baldwin’s gaze was travelling around the room as he spoke. There was no window, just a small door which gave onto the courtyard. When Baldwin walked to it and tried it, it was barred.
Simon gave him an enquiring look, and the knight shrugged. “It means nothing,” he said. “It is barred now, but the murderer might have got in last night and barred it afterward, once he had killed Samuel.”
“What are you saying – that someone in the garrison killed these two?” demanded Sir William, his face reddening.
“Hmm? Oh, yes, without a doubt as far as I’m concerned. Somebody came in here, probably through the locked door, and called out or kicked over a stack of barrels to attract Samuel’s attention. Why else should he come here? When the poor man entered he was grabbed and stabbed in the back. It would not have taken long for him to die, not with a wound that high on his back. Then the same man went through to Ronald’s room and stabbed him through the heart, possibly while he was asleep, but that’s a guess. Whether the dice were already on the floor or not is unimportant, but it is possible the killer scattered them as an afterthought to suggest the idea that there had been a gambling fight. Then it was simply a matter of dropping knives about, after dipping them in blood, to leave us with the clear inference that they must have slaughtered each other. I have no doubt we were expected to think that these two had fallen out over money, but I find it hard – no, impossible – to believe that, after seeing the two of them together. They were too friendly.”
Sir William appeared to shrivel as Baldwin spoke. Simon half-expected the old man to fall to the floor as the knight finished talking, he looked so frail and weak. His face took on an introspective look. “And is there anything else? Anything to indicate who it could have been?” he asked, but Baldwin did not respond. He carried on searching the rooms in his quest for clues while the others watched. They were still there when the servant began pounding on the door and shouting once more for Sir William.
Sir Robert watched his brother with a dry, humorless smile. He had heard of the row of the night before, and was amused to see how it had affected his brother. John stood apart, not wanting to talk to the men-at-arms who helped Robert to his horse, or to the men who climbed on to their own horses to join in the hunt. He waited like a sulking child at the periphery of all the noise as the men prepared.
There was still an all-encompassing smell of burned wood and straw from the stable, and it was partly this which had persuaded Robert to go and search for food. He had no desire to wait in the fort and supervise the men clearing up. After the night before he knew that John would prefer to be leaving the Manor for the morning too, and that gave him cause for a certain sadistic pleasure, knowing he could not go. On a whim he walked his horse over to where his brother stood.
“Come, brother. Why don’t you join us?” John looked up, and Robert saw the despair in his eyes. It made him regret his sarcastic, bantering query, to see his brother so smothered by fears. When he spoke again his voice was softer. “John? Are you all right? Would you like me to stay with you? The men can go alone, if you want to talk.”
“To you?” For a moment all Robert could see was the surprise, and he gave a twisted smile. It did sound odd. For the last few weeks they had quarrelled incessantly, neither wanting to approach too close to the other. Their ideas were too different, their motives, their interests, their very souls, were worlds apart. Each time they came together they sparked, like flint and steel. But it left Robert with a hole he could feel in his heart. He wanted a brother he could call his friend, a man to whom he could talk, with whom he could discuss his anxieties and his hopes, a man he could speak to of his love for Alicia, and who would understand and give encouragement. It was more than that: he needed somebody he could trust wholeheartedly, a man he could rely on, especially now he was to become master of Beauscyr. And especially since the death of Bruther. He leaned forward in his saddle, so that his head was close to his brother’s, and no one else could hear his words.
“Look, John, if you want me to, I’ll stay here to speak to you. You’ll be going soon, I know, and I don’t want you to leave with any bad feelings.” An air of uncertainty crept into his brother’s face and John peered up at him, biting his lip. It emboldened Robert. “When Father is dead and I am master here, you’ll always be welcome to visit, and…”
The spell was broken. With those few words, John lost his indecision. A sneer twisted his features into a grimace of disgust and he took a half-step backward. “So you can feel generous to me, you mean? So you can allow me the scrapings from your table, like an old man begging alms at your door?” Robert wanted to cry out, to stop the flow of spite and jealousy, but the words stuck in his throat. “How kind, brother. How very kind! So you will let me come back here every now and then to see how well you are: how profitable your estate is; how plentiful your children are. I fear, brother, that I might not be able to. I fear that I might prefer to stay in Italy. A jail there would please me more than to see you living here happily, and as far as I am concerned, once our father is dead, I will have no wish to see you or the estate ever again. So thank you, brother. I hope you enjoy your hunt.” And break your damned neck! he added inwardly.