Welcome to the wonderful world of bureaucracy. You can bet that the FBI agent seated on the couch has never found himself in this position before-locked up in chambers in some judge’s courtroom, pulling for the defense in a criminal case.
He sits there quietly watching as his superiors in Washington, who want to make sure they aren’t caught off base, without political cover in the event of a riot following the trial, flush his investigation by outing his undercover agent. And that’s if the Aryan Posse doesn’t kill Henoch before he can testify.
“Your Honor, I have an alternative.” Tuchio finally gets to his punch line. He wants to confer with the FBI and the Justice Department for a moment. They huddle at the couch, murmuring. I can see the agent’s face. At first he seems not to understand what Tuchio is proposing. When he finally gets it, he has another attack, only this one is major, and overt. The agent is sitting there shaking his head, trying to argue with the attorney sitting next to him. It takes a few seconds, but the lawyer from Washington has the final word. He silences him.
Tuchio turns back to the judge. “Your Honor, I would propose that the witness be allowed to testify but that there be no statement or disclosure to the jury that the witness is an agent of the government or involved in any way with law enforcement. It makes perfect sense,” says Tuchio. “It conforms to our earliest disclosure of the witness and his statement.” Then he gets piggy. “In return,” he says, “we would ask that the defense refrain from mentioning or disclosing to the jury the prior convictions of our other witness, Charles Gross.” He sort of slips this in sideways, as if his proffered concession on the agent weren’t being forced.
“That’s not going to happen,” I tell the judge. “Unless-”
“I don’t think so, either,” says Quinn.
“Fine,” says Tuchio, “forget the second part. Gross’s prior record can come in.”
“Unless what?” The judge is looking at me.
The prosecutor’s offer is a bad deal for us any way you cut it. Under Tuchio’s proposal the state has two corroborating witnesses. With Henoch’s testimony, every t crossed and i dotted, and with Gross on the stand later to confirm as much of it as he can remember, it won’t matter that Henoch’s badge is covered up and that Gross’s prior record is out on the table in front of the jury. The details of Henoch’s testimony and the confidence with which he delivers it will kill us. Jurors can smell credibility, and Henoch-or whatever his real name is-will reek of it.
“I have a different proposal, Your Honor. The prosecution presents their testimony through a single witness, Mr. Gross. In return, the defense would refrain from disclosing the witness’s prior convictions.” Then I add the sweetener. “The undercover agent, Walter Henoch-who I assume is already under subpoena?” I look to Tuchio.
“He is.”
“Mr. Henoch will refuse to testify and accordingly will be jailed for contempt.”
At first Tuchio shakes his head and laughs. It takes a second or two before he turns and looks at the FBI agent, a simpering expression on his face like, Why in the hell would we jail one of our own?
But by then the FBI agent is already burrowed deep in the ear of his compatriot from Washington, talking fast enough that you might swear he was going to chew right through to the ear on the other side.
When Tuchio turns to face the judge again, his head all the way to the back of his neck is the color of a ripe radish. He calls it a fraud. “The court in good conscience cannot go along with such a proposal,” he says. “It would be a sham on the judicial process.”
I ask the judge what his powers are if a witness under subpoena refuses to testify.
“Contempt,” says Quinn. “The witness is in the bucket.”
And if there’s one thing that will put your man in tight with his friends in crime, it’s telling a court to go screw itself and doing time at the county lockup, all for the purpose of protecting his buds.
It is exactly the point that the FBI agent has now drilled into the head of the lawyer sitting next to him on the couch. The feds, having been given a glimpse of the nirvana that a little jail time could do to boost their program with the Posse, are having second thoughts.
When Tuchio tries to get them back on board, the lawyer from Justice tells him that the risks involved for their agent are suddenly looking much worse.
Listening to the two feds as they talk on the couch, I can see it’s obvious they think that telling the D.A. and the court to go to hell sounds like a much better idea.
Tuchio stands there burning. It’s the best deal he’s going to get. If he pushes back, I withdraw the offer on Gross’s rap sheet. The look on his face says it all, every four-letter word you can imagine except the one that he actually speaks.
“Fine. I’ll drop Mr. Henoch from my witness list, on the condition that it is part of a deal on the record so that it’s clear I’m not volunteering this.” This he directs to the two feds sitting on the couch. “That Henoch and his statement are unavailable to either side and that Gross’s prior criminal record is off-limits.”
It’s good by me, but I’m not so sure everybody else is happy.
To get out of the judge’s office, Tuchio has to squeeze through the door glued to the two feds, one talking in each of his ears. By now they have come to appreciate fully the unbridled benefits that could be afforded to a scofflaw witness followed quickly by the judge’s hammer.
The day Harry found Scarborough’s shadowed leather portfolio in the police evidence locker, he also noticed a number of boxes, files, and other materials belonging to the victim that authorities had gathered from Scarborough’s apartment in Washington.
Harry looked at the number of boxes and realized that if they were full, and most of them looked as if they were, the volume of materials had to exceed by a considerable amount the documents given to us during discovery by the D.A.’s office. Later, of course, Tuchio dropped the mountain of paper on us right at the start of trial, Scarborough’s computer printouts, and for a few days we thought this might account for the difference.
In the interim, however, Harry had sent one of our paralegals back to the evidence locker to check out the boxes. Jennifer Sanchez is young, pretty, and relentless, not necessarily in that order. Ask her to pick up a piece of lint from your carpet and she’ll vacuum your entire house.
What she found was not paper files but rather DVDs, and some older VCR tapes, hundreds of them dumped into twenty-three cardboard boxes and stacked against the partitions of the evidence locker.
Scarborough apparently had a fetish for making and collecting copies of his appearances on television. From some of the labels, it was clear that at some point he’d hired a company that provided this service, taping his appearances and providing copies. The numbering scheme on the labels, a kind of Dewey decimal system, makes us think that Scarborough, or someone he hired, had probably organized these on shelves or in cabinets in his apartment. But when the authorities grabbed them during their search, they indiscriminately dumped them into boxes. Jennifer found scores of blank tapes and DVD disks, brand-new, still in their original cellophane wrappers mixed in with the copies in the evidence boxes.
Tuchio had in fact disclosed to us the existence of these materials on his police property’s list, in a single line: “Boxes of tapes and digital videos (various).” What this meant was that we were free to look at them whenever we wanted. The D.A.’s office didn’t copy them, and the police probably never looked at them. It would take two lifetimes to view them all.
Whether they even bothered to go through them as Jennifer did, just checking out the labels, we may never know. But this morning, as I was dueling with Tuchio over the FBI, Jennifer hit pay dirt.