‘Tom, you’re turning into a horrible, whining boy,’ I tell him, without any explanation, and without any acknowledgement that he has been created by horrible, whining adults. We finish our walk in silence.

We haven’t had a meal with friends since Before GoodNews, but on the Friday night we go to our friends Andrew and Cam for supper. GoodNews is babysitting: he offered, and the kids seemed OK about it, and as we’d actually failed to arrange an alternative, the offer was gratefully accepted. Andrew and Cam are People Like Us, alarmingly so: Andrew has a perilous toehold on the bottom rung of the media ladder, except it’s not really perilous, because if he lost his footing he wouldn’t actually fall very far, nor would he do himself or his family very much damage. He has a monthly books column in a men’s fitness magazine, and is therefore probably the world’s least-read literary critic. He is, of course, writing something else—a screenplay, rather than a novel, felicitously, so David can commiserate rather than feel threatened, and they can—could—both bitch happily about awful films they have seen or terrible novels they have read, and the bitching miraculously becomes mutually supportive and comradely, rather than merely unpleasant. Cam works in the Health Service as a manager, and she’s nice enough, but we don’t have an awful lot in common: she is Health Service-obsessed and has never wanted children, whereas I am happy never to talk about work if there is another conversational topic, including children, on offer. We are nice to each other because we both recognize the value of this relationship to our angry, frustrated menfolk.

Except now, suddenly, my man is neither angry nor frustrated. Andrew doesn’t know this yet. He phoned, he invited, I accepted, I hung up, and there was no opportunity to mention the Finsbury Park Miracle. David seems unconcerned. In the car on the way over (we usually take a minicab, but David has shown no desire to drink more than the occasional glass of wine, so he is driving), I ask him gently whether he’ll be telling Andrew about GoodNews.

‘Why?’

‘No reason.’

‘Do you think I shouldn’t?’

‘No. I mean… You know, if you want to, you should.’

‘I’ll be perfectly honest with you, Katie. I’ve found it’s quite hard to talk about. Without coming across as a weirdo.’

‘Yes.’

‘Why do you think that is?’

‘I’ve no idea.’

‘People are blinkered, don’t you think?’

‘That must be it. Maybe best to leave the subject alone, then.’

‘I think you’re right. Until I’ve… Until I’ve developed the language to talk about it properly.’

All sorts of muscles all over me relax, and I hadn’t even realized I was tense, although I still get the feeling that this evening might be tricky. ‘What do you think you’ll talk about, then?’

‘I’m sorry?’

‘What do you think we’ll talk about? How will the conversation go?’

‘How should I know? What a peculiar question, Katie. You’ve been for dinner at people’s houses before. You know how it works. Things come up and then we discuss them.’

‘That’s true in theory.’

‘What does that mean?’

‘Well, that’s how it works in most cases. But when we see Andrew and Cam, we walk in, and then Andrew says that so-and-so’s a wanker and his new book is awful, and you say that the new film by somebody else is unintentionally hilarious—even though nine times out of ten I know for a fact you haven’t seen it—and Cam and I sit there smiling and sometimes laughing if you’re being funny instead of just plain nasty, and then you get drunk and tell Andrew he’s a genius, and he gets drunk and tells you you’re a genius, and then we go home.’

David chuckles. ‘Nonsense.’

‘Suit yourself.’

‘Really? That’s your impression of our evenings with Andrew and Cam?’

‘It’s not an impression.’

‘I’m sorry if that’s what you think.’

‘It’s not what I think. It’s what happens.’

‘We’ll see.’

We walk in, we’re offered a drink, we sit down.

‘How are you?’ Cam asks.

‘We’re fine, I think,’ I reply.

‘Better than that fuckwit J—, then,’ says Andrew gleefully. That’s all it takes—‘We’re fine’, because us being fine gives him the opportunity to talk about someone who isn’t fine: J– is a well-known writer who has had a famously bad time of late. His new novel has had unanimously stinking reviews and failed to reach the bestseller lists; meanwhile his wife has left him for one of his younger rivals. The old David would have drunk deep from this cup, but the new one simply looks discomforted.

‘Yes,’ says David mildly. ‘He’s been having a bad time, hasn’t he?’

‘Yes,’ says Andrew. And then, presumably because David has, in his own way, responded to the bit about J– having a bad time, but not to the bit about J– being a fuckwit, he adds, hopefully, ‘Fuckwit.’

‘How are you two?’ says David.

Andrew looks mystified: twice he has offered the hand of enmity, twice it has been refused. He tries one more time. ‘We’re better than that fuckwit J—, too,’ he says, and laughs at his own joke.

‘That’s good,’ says David. ‘I’m glad.’

Andrew chuckles maliciously, as if David has somehow taken the bait. ‘Did you read that review in the Sunday Times? Man, I’d have thrown my WP out of the window and emigrated.’

‘I didn’t read it.’

‘I’ve got it somewhere. I was thinking of having it framed. Shall I dig it out?’

‘No, it’s fine.’

Usually by this point Cam and I have left them to it, and the four has folded neatly into two pairs along the gender crease, but now there is no ‘it’ to which we can leave them, so we sit there listening quietly.

‘How come you missed it?’

‘I… well, I’ve stopped reading reviews. I’m too busy.’

‘Ooooh, get you. That’s put me in my place.’

‘No, no, I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to imply that those who had the time to read reviews were, you know, were inferior in any way. I don’t want to judge anyone.’

‘You don’t want to judge anyone?’ Andrew laughs delightedly. David, the man who sits at the head of the top table in the High Court of all judgements, saying he doesn’t want to judge anyone! This, you can see Andrew thinking, is irony taken to new, impossibly sophisticated levels.

‘So. How come you’re too busy to read reviews all of a sudden? What have you been up to?’

‘Right now I’m… Well, I’m trying to sort out a neighbourhood adopt-a-street-kid campaign sort of thing.’

There is a pause, and both Andrew and Cam study David’s face before the laughter starts again, this time from both of them. The laughter clearly stings David: his ears go red, as if the laughs had little brambles on them that prick him as they enter his head.

‘When you say you’re trying to sort it out,’ says Andrew, ‘do you mean you’re trying to stop it?’

‘No,’ David says meekly. ‘I’m trying to start it.’

The first traces of doubt are visible on Andrew’s face now.

‘How d’you mean?’

‘Oh, it’s a long story. I’ll tell you another time.’

‘Right.’

There is a long, long silence.

‘Who wants to eat?’ Cam says.

Here is a list of the people that Andrew and David have hitherto regarded as talentless, overrated, or simply wankers: Oasis, the Stones, Paul McCartney, John Lennon, Robbie Williams, Kingsley Amis, Martin Amis, Evelyn Waugh, Auberon Waugh, Salman Rushdie, Jeffrey Archer, Tony Blair, Gordon Brown, William Shakespeare (although to be fair they despise the comedies and some of the history plays only), Charles Dickens, E. M. Forster, Daniel Day-Lewis, the Monty Python team, Gore Vidal, John Updike, Thomas Harris, Gabriel García Márquez, Milan Kundera, Damien Hirst, Tracey Emin, Melvyn Bragg, Dennis Bergkamp, David Beckham, Ryan Giggs, Sam Mendes, Anthony Burgess, Virginia Woolf, Michael Nyman, Philip Glass, Steven Spielberg, Leonardo DiCaprio, Ted Hughes, Mark Hughes, Sylvia Plath, Stevie Smith, Maggie Smith, the Smiths, Alan Ayckbourn, Harold Pinter, David Mamet, Tom Stoppard, of course, all other contemporary playwrights, Garrison Keillor, Sue Lawley, James Naughtie, Jeremy Paxman, Carole King, James Taylor, Kenneth Branagh, Van Morrison, Jim Morrison, Courtney Love, Courteney Cox and the entire cast of Friends, Ben Elton, Stephen Fry, Andre Agassi, Pete Sampras and all contemporary male tennis players, Monica Seles and all female tennis players throughout history, Pele, Maradona, Linford Christie, Maurice Greene (‘How can a sprinter who’s faster than anyone else be overrated?’ I asked once, despairingly, but I received no satisfactory reply), T. S. Eliot and Ezra Pound, Gilbert and Sullivan, Gilbert and George, Ben and Jerry, Powell and Pressburger, Marks and Spencer, the Coen Brothers, Stevie Wonder, Nicole Farhi and anyone who designs fucking suits for a living, Naomi Campbell, Kate Moss, Johnny Depp, Stephen Sondheim, Bart Simpson (but not Homer Simpson), Homer, Virgil, Coleridge, Keats and all the Romantic poets, Jane Austen, all the Brontës, all the Kennedys, the people who made the film of Trainspotting, the people who made the film of Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, Madonna, the Pope, anyone they were at school or college with who is now making a name for themselves in the fields of journalism, broadcasting or the arts, and many, many others, so many others, too many to list here. It is easier, in fact, to write down the people in world history that they both like: Bob Dylan (although not recently), Graham Greene, Quentin Tarantino and Tony Hancock. I can’t remember anyone else ever receiving the double thumbs-up from these two guardians of our culture.