Ulrich looked up with an inquiring frown. "When was that?"

"The night he came to search the convent library."

"You believe it was he who murdered the recluse?"

"Aye."

"Ah, yes. Our mysterious ghost who walks through locked gates," Ulrich said thoughtfully.

"More likely a man in a monk's cowl who knows how to pick a lock. I suspect he came and went in a small boat that he brought ashore at one of these two locations." Gareth stabbed a finger at the small coves drawn on the map.

Ulrich smiled without any of his usual amusement. "If the magician returns a second time, we'll have him."

"Aye. He's only a man, despite what Dalian believes."

"Where is young Dalian?"

"Clare took him out to the kitchens to feed him. He's suddenly starving now that he has recovered from his adventures and no longer fears he will be hung."

Ulrich frowned in thought. "I would like more information about this magician."

"As would I. But Dalian's fear of him is such that he finds it difficult to speak of him. Clare says the minstrel will become more talkative once he is fed."

"You have assigned your lady to question the boy?"

"It was Clare's idea," Gareth admitted.

"He's a magician?" Joanna's mouth fell open in astonishment. "Are you certain?"

"That's what Dalian claims." Clare looked at Dalian. "Is that not so?"

"Aye, my lady." Dalian sat at the trestle table in the kitchen. He had a large slice of leftover roast chicken in front of him which he was devouring with the air of a man who had not eaten in weeks. William sat across from him, nibbling on a bit of cheese.

"Sir Ulrich says there is no such thing as magic," William said. "He says Lucretius de Valemont is likely an alchemist, not a real magician."

"Lucretius de Valemont can walk through locked doors," Dalian insisted.

"Is that true?" William asked, intrigued.

"I have seen him enter a locked chamber without using a key," Dalian said around a mouthful of chicken. "I have also seen him make objects appear and disappear. I know that Lord Gareth does not believe me, but 'tis true."

"I'll wager he is not a great knight like Lord Gareth and Sir Ulrich,"

William said confidently.

Dalian stopped chewing. His eyes were troubled. "I told you, Lucretius de Valemont went on Crusade.

He is a fierce knight, although he says only a fool uses a sword when he can use magic."

William took another bite of his cheese. "Is he as large and strong as Lord Gareth and Sir Ulrich?"

"Nay." Dalian looked more cheerful for a moment. "He is not as large as my lord." His face fell again. "But he is very skilled with a sword. And he is extremely clever. He says big men are easy to defeat because they always rely on their muscles instead of their wits."

"The magician has obviously not met Lord Gareth, has he?" Clare sat down on the bench beside William and looked across at Dalian.

"Nay." Dalian appeared to relax slightly at that thought. "Lord Gareth is very clever, too, is he not? Mayhap he is even more clever than the magician."

"I expect he is." Clare helped herself to a slice of hot bread. "Is the magician married?"

"Nay. Women find him handsome. Indeed, they are much taken with him. I have often seen them vie for his attention. But he says he has little use for females."

Joanna set out a portion of custard. Her eyes met Clare's. "Does he prefer the company of men, then?" she asked very casually.

Dalian shrugged. "Nay."

"Young boys, mayhap?" Joanna suggested quietly.

Clare held her breath as she realized the implications of Joanna's question.

But Dalian merely seemed confused by the remark. He shook his head and helped himself to the custard. "Nay. In truth, the magician does not care for anyone. He is devoted to his studies of the black arts. But I have seen him be most courteous to ladies when he wants something from them."

Clare did not move. "What do you mean?"

"He gives them romantic gifts when he wishes to lure them into doing some service for him."

"What sort of gifts?" Clare asked.

"A single blood-red rose. Sometimes he composes poetry for them, even though he thinks it foolish." Dalian grimaced. "The ladies are much impressed by such gifts. They do not know that he feels nothing for them."

"A single blood-red rose." Clare drummed her fingers lightly on the table. "Tell me, Dalian, does the magician perfume his clothing or use a scented soap?"

"Nay. He does not care for perfumes and scents. He says they are for women, but in truth, I believe he does not like them because some of them make him sneeze."

Clare exchanged a glance with Joanna. "What color hair does the magician have?"

"He is fair." Dalian looked at her. "Why do you ask?"

"With golden brown eyes?"

"Aye." Dalian frowned. "How did you know?"

Clare met Joanna's uneasy gaze. "'Twas a guess based on some of the other things you have said of him."

William was visibly impressed. "But how did you guess the color of his eyes, Lady Clare?"

"I believe we know this magician, William."

"We have made his acquaintance?" William stared at her.

"Aye."

"But that is impossible," William said.

"Dear God," Joanna whispered. She met Clare's gaze with dawning horror.

"Surely you do not believe?"

"Aye, I do." Clare's mouth tightened. "Think on it, Joanna. He is in the habit of giving ladies a single blood-red rose. He composes poetry for them. He is a courteous knight who studies the secrets of the Arabic texts. He is medium-sized and scoffs at large men who rely on their strength. And he does not care for perfume because some recipes make him sneeze."

"And," Gareth said quietly from the doorway, "he knows a great deal about this isle and this hall.

Enough to send Dalian here with clear instructions on how to ingratiate himself into this household."

"My lord." Dalian leaped to his feet. "I did not hear you come in."

William scowled. "I don't understand. Who is this magician?"

Clare looked at Gareth, whose gray eyes matched the color of the sky behind him. He watched her intently, waiting for her answer.

"We knew him as Raymond de Coleville," Clare said.

"By the saints," Joanna whispered. "Your handsome Raymond?"

"Aye." Clare did not take her gaze off Gareth's grim face. "Well, that's a relief, is it not?"

"Why is it a relief?" Dalian asked.

"Because I know both Sir Raymond and Lord Gareth very well." Clare rose to her feet and gazed at the expectant faces surrounding her. She smiled calmly. "And I can assure you that the magician is no match for our Hellhound."

Gareth stood at the window of Clare's study chamber and gazed out over the sea. There was an unpleasant gray mist pooling above the steel-colored waves. It had the look of a dense fog that could quickly shroud the isle.

"He was your ideal knight, the pattern of chivalry on which you based your recipe for a husband,"

Gareth said without any inflection in his voice.

"Tis true, I used Raymond de Coleville as a model." Clare sat very straight in her chair and clasped her hands on top of her desk. "A woman needs a basic recipe to work from, after all."

"Does she?"

Clare sighed. "I have not made the acquaintance of many knights, my lord. The few I have known were not very impressive. They tended to resemble Sir Nicholas or my brother. My father was a knight and I held him in great affection, but I certainly did not want a husband who shirked his responsibilities as he did."

"And then the magician appeared here on your isle and cast his spells on you."