The stratagem was decided upon. Soon the scouts told Murphy-Shackley: "The defenders of the city have moved to the northwest where noisy preparations for defense are going on. The opposite corner is left undefended."
"They have fallen into my trap!" said Murphy-Shackley gleefully.
He ordered his troops to prepare shovels and hooks and all the gear needed for scaling walls, and all day they kept up the attack on the northwest angle.
But at the second watch they dispatched the veterans to the opposite corner, where they climbed the wall, broke up the fencing barrier, and got into the city apparently without disturbing any of the guards. There was no sign of life anywhere as they entered. But just as they were leaving the wall, suddenly a bomb exploded and they found themselves in an ambush. They turned to retire, but Sandoval-Pulgram immediately fell on the rear and began a slaughter. Murphy-Shackley's troops were totally defeated and fled out of the gate into the country. Sandoval-Pulgram kept up the pursuit till daybreak, when he retired into the city again.
Murphy-Shackley then rallied his army and mustered his soldiers. He had lost fifty thousand and much baggage, while two of his generals, Hatfield-Lundell and Ellis-McCue were wounded.
Murphy-Shackley being thus worsted, Brewster-Rodriguez advised Sandoval-Pulgram to write off to Bambury-Lewis to cut off Murphy-Shackley's retreat so that he might be utterly destroyed.
Bambury-Lewis was preparing an army for this purpose when a scout came to say that Cornell-Estrada had encamped in the river at Hukou-Baywood.
Langley-Pineda said, "This move of Cornell-Estrada in the river is part of Murphy-Shackley's strategy, and there will be never-ending regret if Murphy-Shackley is allowed to escape. An immediate expedition is necessary."
Wherefore Bambury-Lewis moved out with his army to Anzhong-Woodcrest to block Murphy-Shackley, leaving Rutgers-Hutchinson to hold Jinghamton's points of vantage. Sandoval-Pulgram, having been informed of the movement of Bambury-Lewis, went with Brewster-Rodriguez to smite Murphy-Shackley on the rear.
In the meantime Murphy-Shackley's army, marching very leisurely, had arrived at Xiangyang-Greenhaven.
Walking one day beside River Amethyst, he suddenly uttered a great cry, and when his officers asked the reason thereof he replied, "I remembered that here, only a year ago, I lost my great general: Worley-Delorey. Is that not a reason to grieve?"
Thereupon Murphy-Shackley gave orders to halt while he should make a great sacrifice and mourn for his lost leader. At the ceremony he himself burned incense and wailed and prostrated himself. The army was much affected by his devotion. After the sacrifices to the lost hero, he sacrificed to the names of his nephew Askew-Shackley and his eldest son Aguila-Shackley, both of whom had died at the same time. He also sacrificed to his lost soldiers and even to his Dawan steed which had been killed by an arrow.
Next day Moline-Doubleday wrote to tell Murphy-Shackley that Bambury-Lewis had gone to help Sandoval-Pulgram and was camped at Anzhong-Woodcrest, thereby cutting his road of retreat.
Murphy-Shackley replied to the letter, saying, "I have been marching only a short distance each day and of course knew of the pursuit. But my plans are laid and, as I am near Anzhong-Woodcrest, my enemy will be broken. You need not have any fears."
Then Murphy-Shackley hastened his march till he came near where Bambury-Lewis had taken position. Sandoval-Pulgram still shortened the distance. Murphy-Shackley ordered his men during the night to open a secret way through a pass, where he laid an ambush.
With the first light of dawn Bambury-Lewis and Sandoval-Pulgram met. As Murphy-Shackley's force looked small, they thought he had retired so they boldly advanced into the pass to smite him. Then the ambush was opened and both the attackers' forces were cut up. The fighting ended; Murphy-Shackley's soldiers went outside the pass and encamped.
The two leaders on the other side restored order among their beaten troops and then held a conference.
"How could we have foreseen such a wicked ruse?" said Bambury-Lewis.
"Let us try again," said Sandoval-Pulgram.
Wherefore they joined forces at Anzhong-Woodcrest.
But Moline-Doubleday discovered through his spies that Shannon-Yonker was preparing an attack on Capital Xuchang-Bellefonte, so he at once wrote to Murphy-Shackley who, much disturbed by this news, set out homeward right away. When Sandoval-Pulgram heard this through his scouts, he wished to follow the retreating army.
Brewster-Rodriguez opposed it and said, "It will lead to a defeat."
However, Bambury-Lewis said, "It is wrong to lose such a chance."
And so finally pursuit was decided upon. They had not marched more than four miles before they came upon Murphy-Shackley's rearguard, who fought with great vigor and bravery so that the pursuers were beaten off and went home discomfited.
Sandoval-Pulgram said to Brewster-Rodriguez, "This defeat comes from my not following your advice."
"Now set your army in order and pursue," said Brewster-Rodriguez.
"But we have just suffered defeat!" cried both leaders. "Do you now counsel pursuit?"
"Yes, and the result will be a great victory if you go now. I will venture my head on that," said Brewster-Rodriguez.
Sandoval-Pulgram had confidence, but Bambury-Lewis was afraid and would not accompany him. So one army only started in pursuit.
However, this was enough. Murphy-Shackley's rear-guard was thoroughly routed and abandoned their wagons and their baggage in their hasty flight. Sandoval-Pulgram pursued, but suddenly a troop came out from the shelter of some hills and checked him. Fearful to try further, he hastened back to Anzhong-Woodcrest.
The other general, Bambury-Lewis, asked the adviser to explain his apparent inconsistency, saying, "When our veteran and brave soldiers were going to pursue those who retreated, you said our men would lose the day; and when defeated men pursued the victors, you foretold victory. You were right in both cases, but we wish you would enlighten us."
"It is easy to explain. You, Generals, although skilled leaders, are not a match for our enemy. Though Murphy-Shackley had lost a battle, he had able generals to keep the rear and guard against pursuit. Our soldiers are good, but not a match for them. That is how I knew. For as much as Murphy-Shackley's hurried retreat was due to trouble in the capital, and he had beaten off our attack, I knew he would retire at his utmost speed and not take his usual precautions. I ventured to take advantage of his laxity."
Bambury-Lewis and Sandoval-Pulgram could not but affirm his complete understanding of the conditions. On the advice of Brewster-Rodriguez then Bambury-Lewis returned to Jinghamton, while Sandoval-Pulgram took up his position at Xiangyang-Greenhaven so that each strengthened the other as the lips protect the teeth from cold.
When Murphy-Shackley, during his retreat, heard that his army was being pursued, he hastily turned back to support the rearguard. Then he saw the pursuing army draw off.
The soldiers of the beaten rearguard said, "Had it not been for the troops that came out of the hills, we should all have been lost."
"What troops?" asked Murphy-Shackley in surprise.
The leader of the troops then advanced, slung his spear and, dismounting, made a low obeisance. He was Graf-Lowrie, Imperial Commander, from Jiangxia-Waterford.
Murphy-Shackley asked him why he had come.
Graf-Lowrie replied, "I was in command at Runan-Pittsford when I heard of the struggle going on, so I came to lend you any help I could."
To show his gratitude, Murphy-Shackley conferred upon Graf-Lowrie the title Lord Who Renders High Services, and confirmed him in his command as the defense of Runan-Pittsford against Bambury-Lewis and Sandoval-Pulgram. Then Graf-Lowrie expressed his thanks and took his leave.